Phmsa Triskelion Logo United States Department of Transportation

Improving Leak Detection System Design Redundancy & Accuracy

Overview

Fast Facts

Project No. 560
Contract No. DTPH56-14-H-00007
Research Award Recipient Kiefner and Associates, Inc. 6185 Huntley Road – Suite J Columbus, OH 43229
AOR Max Kieba
Researcher Contact Info Principal Investigator: Harvey Haines 703-635-2726 Harvey.Haines@applusrtd.com
Peer Review More than Effective
Peer Review Very Effective
Peer Review More than Effective

Financial and Status Data

Project Status Closed
Start Fiscal Year 2014 (01/01/2014)
End Fiscal Year 2017 (12/31/2016)
PHMSA $$ Budgeted $832,036.00

Main Objective

Leak detection systems are an important part of any overall pipeline safety and integrity strategy. The benefits of reliably and rapidly identifying a leak, so that the resulting fluid loss can be controlled and contained as soon as possible, can be very significant, particularly in High Consequence Areas (HCAs). The mission of this project is standardize the approach to designing an appropriate LDS for all pipelines, and that will be accessible to all operators – including the smaller ones – without extended and laborious front-end engineering. A central part of this approach is to concentrate upon certain key issues:

  1. Beginning any LDS design process with a systematic focus on assessing requirements.
  2. Accepting that one single technology will probably not provide perfect performance for all objectives, on a given pipeline. Therefore, a key issue is exploring ways to combine multiple technologies / physical principles into one system in order to address each requirement optimally.
  3. Allowing the operator to be able to predict performance – and therefore cost/benefit – more reliably from the design.

Public Abstract

Leak detection systems (LDS) are an important part of an overall pipeline safety strategy. The benefits of rapidly identifying a leak are significant, particularly in High Consequence Areas (HCAs). LDS that are unreliable or insensitive are a problem. An operator with an LDS that frequently calls false alarms will regularly ignore them. Similarly, an insensitive LDS wastes money as large leaks occur before an alarm is given, while small leaks may go undetected for long periods. Leak detection is a complex engineering problem. Different pipelines have different requirements. There is no "one size fits all" LDS solution and currently there are no universally accepted design standards. This project will develop recommendations, expert guidance and draft procedures to standardize designing LDS for all pipelines, including smaller ones, without costly front-end engineering. The project will concentrate on the key issues: 1) The LDS design process with a systematic focus on assessing requirements. 2) One single technology will not provide optimal performance on a pipeline. 3) Allowing the operator to predict system performance and cost/benefit from the design process. The results of this project will be source documents and expert LDS guidance for use in operations and for developers of pipeline standards and regulatory content. An Industry Technical Committee will assist with achieving these deliverables.

Summary and Conclusions

The results of the project project serve as source documents and expert guidance for use in operations and are potentially a reference for developers of pipeline procedures and best practices with regards to accessibility, reduction of front-end engineering, and standardization of the approach for designing an LDS. It was not intended that this project alone produce recommended practices or standards.

Relevant Files & Links

Final Report

Final Report for Hazardous Liquid Pipelines

01A_DTPH5614H000007_-_Liquids_Final_Report.pdf

Final Report for Natural Gas Transmission Pipelines

02A_DTPH5614H000007_-_Natural_Gas_Final_Report.pdf

Other Files

Improving Leak Detection System Design, Redundancy and Accuracy Hazardous Liquid Pipelines: Appendices (Final)

01C DTPH5614H000007_-_0339-1404_Final_Appendix_Liquids.pdf

Toolset: Basic Risk Assessment Template - Liquid Pipelines (Final)

01D Template_Pipeline_LDCE_LIQUIDS_-_Final.xlsx

Improving Leak Detection System Design, Redundancy and Accuracy Natural Gas Pipelines: Appendices (Final)

02B DTPH5614H000007_-_0339-1404_Final_Appendix_Gas.pdf

Toolset: Basic Risk Assessment Template - Natural Gas Pipelines (Final)

02C Template_Pipeline_LDCE_GAS_-_Final.xlsx

Toolset: Leak Detection System - Requirements and Considerations (Final)

03A Template_Requirements-Considerations_-_Final.xlsx

Toolset: Template for Leak Detection Technology Selection (Final)

03B Template_Technology_Selection_-_Final.xlsx

Toolset: Template for Leak Detection System Testing and Maintenance (Final)

03C Template_Testing-Maintenance_-_Final.xlsx